I have no problem with the jury verdict in this case. It seems appropriate to essentially tell the Doctor that what he did was not appropriate and slap him on the wrist ($2000 fine, misdemeanors conviction). While I can not fault him for his actions, it was against the law.
HOWEVER, I think the "kids" should also be charged. Criminal trespass, criminal mischief, SOMETHING. Going up to someones door and violently rattling it at 10:30pm at night is more than ding-dong ditch. It would not have surprised me if they had ended up shot... if multiple cars pulled into my driveway, a group of men hopped out that I didn't know, and then ran up and appeared to be attempting to break in my front door - it would not end well for them. At very least their intent was to put the people inside in "imminent fear of harm."
I agree solidly CF. Disclosure: I am lightly acquainted with the Dr. and his wife. There is more to the story of course as always. They had been harassing his family for some time. The parents were aware and their response was a poor example of parenting. Nonetheless, the doc's response was over the top. It seems we think professionals are immune to these kinds of reactions and that is just not true. Most of us would have behaved similarly if we felt threatened, yet the response was disproportionate. I hope the misdemeanor does not affect his creditation.
The parents need to get a grip and drop any civil suits. Print their photos in the local rag so we can all see the faces of poor parenting....south of 91st street.
